Greek Church strongly considering recognizing Ukrainian schismatics under influence of Met. Hierotheos (Vlachos)

Athens, August 16, 2019

Photo: Orthodox Ethos Photo: Orthodox Ethos     

While the Orthodox Church of Greece has yet to make any official decision regarding the Constantinople-created “Orthodox Church of Ukraine” (OCU), new information indicates that that the hierarchs are strongly considering recognizing the schismatic structure.

Moreover, Constantinople’s continuing pressure could lead to a schism among the 20 ruling monasteries of Mt. Athos.

The OCU was created in December and granted a tomos of autocephaly by Constantinople in January, but has thus far failed to achieve recognition by any Church other than Constantinople. Several branches of Orthodoxy, including the Serbian Church, the Polish Church, and the Orthodox Church in America have rejected and explicitly referred to the OCU as schismatics. Several others have expressed serious concerns and called for a pan-Orthodox council to resolve the ongoing issue.

Certain hierarchs of the Greek Church have effectively recognized the OCU for themselves: Several have already concelebrated with representatives of the OCU, and an archimandrite from the Metropolis of Demetrias and Almyros was even released to become a “bishop” in the OCU. There have been no reports of any of these hierarchs being reprimanded or sanctioned by the Greek Synod in any way.

However, the most influential voice in the Greek Church in favor of recognizing the OCU, has been His Eminence Metropolitan Hierotheos (Vlachos) of Nafpaktos, an internationally-recognized theologian. Met. Hierotheos has not served with the OCU, but has written several essays detailing his view of the prerogatives of the Patriarchate of Constantinople and arguing that the Greek Church (and, in fact, no Local Church) has no right to object to what Constantinople has done. The OCU must be accepted, he writes, until a pan-Orthodox council can take up the matter.

OrthoChristian has published a critique of some of the Metropolitan’s statements.

His latest essay, “The ecclesiastical ebbs and flows of the Moscow Patriarchate,” notes that “anti-ecumenists in Greece strongly judge and criticize the Ecumenical Patriarchate, and in particular Ecumenical Patriarch Bartholomew, while pardoning the other Orthodox Churches, and in particular the Russian Orthodox Church.”

While it is debatable whether anti-ecumenists give a pass to the Russian Church, His Eminence rightly points to the problematic Havana Document, signed by His Holiness Patriarch Kirill of Moscow and Russia and Pope Francis in February 2016. However, the fact that he did not speak out against the document at that time, but only now, more than 3 years later, gives the impression that his critique serves only as a distraction from Constantinople’s invasion of the Ukrainian Church’s canonical territory. The respected theologian also makes the outlandish claim that in signing the document, Pat. Kirill believed he was signing on behalf of the entire Orthodox Church. In playing on fears of the non-existent “Third Rome” doctrine, Met. Hierotheos has only hurt his own reputation.

OrthoChristian offered several critiques of the Havana Document a few days after its signing. See here and here.

According to a source familiar with the atmosphere in the Greek Church and with its important figures, Met. Hierotheos’ writings have had a major impact and are one of the main reasons why the Church of Greece is now considering supporting Constantinople in its Ukrainian affair.

“This would be catastrophic for the Orthodox in the Greek-speaking world,” says the source.

Among the more traditionally-minded in Greece, there is a fear that if Constantinople’s power grab and test run for expanded powers is accepted by the Greek Church, the struggle for the purity of the Orthodox faith will only become that much more difficult.

Judging by the number of bishops who are going along with Constantinople and provoking the rest of the Greek Church to accept the OCU, the outcome does not look good, according to our source, who also notes that there have been only a scant few voices speaking out against recognizing the OCU, including Metropolitans Seraphim of Piraeus (and here) Nektarios of Corfu, Paxoi, and the Diapontian Islands, Seraphim of Kythira, and Ambrose of Kalavryta.

Fr. Theodore Zisis has also taken a principled stand, lamenting the position of Met. Hierotheos, who once bravely withstood the Patriarchate of Constantinople at the Crete Council.

While the Greek Church may have decided to recognize the OCU anyways, Met. Hierotheos’ influence has made it much more likely.

The same fears are held by a number of abbots on Mt. Athos. Pat. Bartholomew will visit the Holy Mountain in October, and more than one abbot has resolved to cease commemoration of the Patriarch if he brings “Metropolitan” Epiphany Dumenko, the primate of the OCU, with him. The Ukrainian question has already caused tension and divisions on the Mountain.

It is unclear when the bishops of the Church of Greece will make a formal decision on the Ukrainian question.

Follow us on Facebook and Twitter!

8/16/2019

See also
Archbishop of Greece meets Ukrainian schismatic primate in Istanbul Archbishop of Greece meets Ukrainian schismatic primate in Istanbul Archbishop of Greece meets Ukrainian schismatic primate in Istanbul Archbishop of Greece meets Ukrainian schismatic primate in Istanbul
Epiphany and Abp. Ieronymos greeted one another and were seated next to one another throughout the Vespers service, marking Epiphany’s first meeting with the primate of a Local Church besides Pat. Bartholomew.
Abbots of Mt. Athos ask Ukrainian pilgrims to bring official statement of belonging to canonical Church Abbots of Mt. Athos ask Ukrainian pilgrims to bring official statement of belonging to canonical Church Abbots of Mt. Athos ask Ukrainian pilgrims to bring official statement of belonging to canonical Church Abbots of Mt. Athos ask Ukrainian pilgrims to bring official statement of belonging to canonical Church
The ongoing Ukrainian Church crisis continues to cause a disturbance on the Holy Mountain, where many monks are caught between the long-standing Athonite tradition of guarding the purity of the faith and the unity of the Church on one hand, and obedience to their hierarch, Patriarch Bartholomew, on the other.
Archbishop Ieronymos Has Reached a Dead End on Ukraine Archbishop Ieronymos Has Reached a Dead End on Ukraine
Fr. Theodore Zisis
Archbishop Ieronymos Has Reached a Dead End on Ukraine Archbishop Ieronymos Has Reached a Dead End on Ukraine
Patriarch Bartholomew is Isolated: The Danger of Ethnophyletism
Fr. Theodore Zisis
As of today, four of the five Grecophone Churches have not united with the Constantinople Church, while the fifth—the Church of Greece—is waiting and remaining silent. Furthermore, two Churches, of Cyprus and Albania, have synodically resolved to require that a Pan-Orthodox Council be convened to decide the Ukraine question.
It is Unacceptable to Have Eucharistic Communion with Unordained Schismatics It is Unacceptable to Have Eucharistic Communion with Unordained Schismatics
Met. Nikiforos of Kykkos
It is Unacceptable to Have Eucharistic Communion with Unordained Schismatics It is Unacceptable to Have Eucharistic Communion with Unordained Schismatics
Commentary on the Ukrainian Issue for the Cypriot Holy Synod
Metropolitan Nikiforos of Kykkos
I can draw only one conclusion. Sadly enough, Ecumenical Patriarch Bartholomew’s granting of autocephalous status to the schismatic community of Philaret and Epiphany not only did not heal the existing schism in Ukraine, but on the contrary, aggravated it.
Greek Church under pressure from political, economic, diplomatic fields to recognize Ukrainian schismatics Greek Church under pressure from political, economic, diplomatic fields to recognize Ukrainian schismatics Greek Church under pressure from political, economic, diplomatic fields to recognize Ukrainian schismatics Greek Church under pressure from political, economic, diplomatic fields to recognize Ukrainian schismatics
The Church has received and examined letters from His Holiness Patriarch Kirill of Moscow and All Russia, Patriarch Bartholomew, and the schismatic “Metropolitan” Epiphany Dumenko on the matter, but the bishops have yet to take a stance, despite the strong statements of individual hierarchs.
Metropolis of Piraeus calls on Greek Holy Synod not to recognize Ukrainian schismatics Metropolis of Piraeus calls on Greek Holy Synod not to recognize Ukrainian schismatics Metropolis of Piraeus calls on Greek Holy Synod not to recognize Ukrainian schismatics Metropolis of Piraeus calls on Greek Holy Synod not to recognize Ukrainian schismatics
The Metropolis of Piraeus, headed by His Eminence Metropolitan Seraphim of Piraeus, has called on the Holy Synod of the Greek Orthodox Church not to recognize the so-called “Orthodox Church of Ukraine” created by Patriarch Bartholomew of Constantinople and President Petro Poroshenko of Ukraine on December 15.

Subscribe
to our mailing list

* indicates required
×