What's Really Behind the Persecution of Christians in the Middle East?

SOURCE: Catholic Online

"Let justice roll down like waters, and righteousness like an ever-flowing stream" (Amos 5:24).

Although it has fallen largely on deaf ears, the plight of Christians in the Middle East has made some news, especially in Christian circles. I have written on the circumstances there, myself, and about how Muslim extremism is the main cause of escalating emigration, the destruction of Coptic churches, and the approaching extinction of Christians in the region.

Recently, however, my view of the problem was carefully challenged by a Catholic brother whose vocation is intimately involved with the difficulties in the Middle East. I began to research the topic much more thoroughly, even speaking to Christians in Bethlehem and Jerusalem. With a heavy heart I must confess I was wrong about a great many matters, and am guilty of ignorantly contributing to the real problem by spreading what amounts to propaganda.  

Palestinian Christians in Church of Saint Porphyrius of Gaza by Joe Catron Palestinian Christians in Church of Saint Porphyrius of Gaza by Joe Catron
    

Prayer for Christian Unity in Armenian Orthodox St. James Church, Jerusalem, Palestine Prayer for Christian Unity in Armenian Orthodox St. James Church, Jerusalem, Palestine
    

A Palestinian boy takes part in the Eastern Orthodox Christmas procession outside the Church of the Nativity in the West Bank town of Bethlehem,Palestine A Palestinian boy takes part in the Eastern Orthodox Christmas procession outside the Church of the Nativity in the West Bank town of Bethlehem,Palestine
    

When asked directly about the causes for the emigration and elimination of Christians from the area, Israeli and Palestinian Christians overwhelmingly indicate that the primary causes are political and economic conditions, not religious extremism. 87.3% of the respondents in a 2006 study of 1500 Christian families in Palestine and Israel said the same. Only 8% attributed emigration to religious extremism (pg. 34, Sabeel survey with Bethlehem University). The truth, it seems, is that religious extremism contributes, but not in the way I previously thought. More on that in a moment.

In their own words, many Christians in the area say it is not the movement of Muslims into the area or Islamic violence, but brutal economic conditions that proceed from the political climate between Israel and Palestine that are forcing Christians to leave and inciting violence.

Most of the land taken by Israeli settlement expansion belonged to Palestinian Christians, including the seizure of lands belonging to the Convent of Cremisan. The Separation Wall, built under the guise of security, physically split Christian families and closed Christian businesses.

Against an exhortation for Israel to reconsider by the USCCB and brother bishops all over the world, the Wall devoured land privately owned by indigenous Christian people, split a Salesian religious community offering services and ministering there in two, and illegally confiscated and destroyed Christian vineyards and olive groves held and cultivated by Christians for generations.

In addition to the Wall, the Israeli occupation and its security checkpoint and permit system greatly restricts Christian movement, especially to Jerusalem and other Christian holy sites. My Catholic brother shared that a group of Christians he was with at Christmas was uncomfortable with their worship at the Church of the Nativity in Bethlehem because the tension and scrutiny was so thick.

Israel's separation Wall, illegal confiscation of Palestinian land, policies that violate freedom, and its brutal crackdowns on nonviolent protests have decimated the economic stability of the entire area and pushed not only Christians to emigrate, but also many other Palestinians.

Candidly, to the Palestinian Christians there the Wall is a big "push factor" for forcing Palestinians out of Palestine, many of whom are Christian. But Muslims leave as well. According to one of the Palestinian Christians I spoke with, religious violence from Jewish settlers has also made the lives of Palestinian Muslims miserable and intolerable.

Such Israeli activity prompted the heads of the Catholic churches in the Holy Land last year to label it unjust and meet with Pope Francis about the extent of Israeli oppression and the suffering of Christians there. At the time the Wall was still being considered, they also called for the realignment of its plan in accordance with international law, pointing out to the Israeli decision-makers that "illegal seizure of lands in no way serves the cause of peace, nor does it support the moderate position that opts for non-violence."

The churches spoke prophetically. Blatant, chronic injustice and instability causes anxiety, discouragement, despair, and retaliation. Israel and her allies in the world blame Islam, and militant Muslim terrorists everywhere use the accusation to retaliate. Palestinian Christians beg us not to "exploit [their] sufferings to fuel some islamophobic tendencies and negative images about Islam. Indeed, this is what the Israeli occupation persistently tries to do. It demonizes Islam in a way that deflects blame from the repression levied by the state itself."

Religious extremism contributes, but we must not single out Islamic extremists as the sole threat to Christian presence in the area. According to Palestinian Christians, there are also Jewish extremists represented by what they call "religious and racist" settlers on the West Bank. They maintain that they are encouraged directly by the Israeli government and by, in their words, "Christian extremists represented by Western Christians that support Israel blindly and unconditionally."

With candor they maintain that these last two groups are a greater threat to Christians in the Middle East than the Muslim extremists, because they have more money, military power, and clout to uproot all Palestinian presence, both Christian and Muslim, from their homeland.

To be fair, it is also widely known in the region that without Israeli control, the area would undoubtedly degenerate into factious religious wars within a decade or so. The issues are too intricately complicated to support easy answers. But no real peace can or will ever come from the injustice perpetrated on the area by some aspects of current Israeli methodology.

The most heartbreaking bit I learned about the situation and suffering of our Catholic Christian brothers and sisters in the Middle East was this statement from a Palestinian Christian leader: "We are no longer expecting support from Church leaders around the world. Our Hope, Faith and Love come from elsewhere. Palestinian Christians need advocates for the truth. It is the truth, and only the truth, that will lead to peace and justice in our home."

2/19/2014

See also
Patriarch of Antioch: Patriarch of Antioch: "The Jihadists are a Foreign Body"
An Interview with Patriarch John X in Greece
Patriarch of Antioch: Patriarch of Antioch: "The Jihadists are a Foreign Body"
An Interview with Patriarch John X in Greece
In his interview with VIMA, Patriarch John of Antioch highlighted the necessity of international mobilization for peace in the Middle East and the release of the two bishops of Aleppo who were kidnapped 18 months ago on the Turkish-Syrian border.
We must stand up for Middle East's persecuted Christians We must stand up for Middle East's persecuted Christians We must stand up for Middle East's persecuted Christians We must stand up for Middle East's persecuted Christians
Christianity began in the East, not the West, yet today Christians in the East are enduring an all-out-assault by Islamic terrorists, while Christians in the West live their lives largely oblivious to it all.
Palestinians mark subdued Christmas at Gaza’s Orthodox church Palestinians mark subdued Christmas at Gaza’s Orthodox church Palestinians mark subdued Christmas at Gaza’s Orthodox church Palestinians mark subdued Christmas at Gaza’s Orthodox church
Israel granted several hundred Christian Palestinians aged under 16 or over 35 short-term permits to travel to the occupied West Bank to participate in Christmas celebrations in recent weeks.
As-Safir on the History of the Persecution of Middle Eastern Christians As-Safir on the History of the Persecution of Middle Eastern Christians As-Safir on the History of the Persecution of Middle Eastern Christians As-Safir on the History of the Persecution of Middle Eastern Christians
Christian Decline in the Middle East: A Historical View
The winter of Christian discontent in the Arab world The winter of Christian discontent in the Arab world The winter of Christian discontent in the Arab world The winter of Christian discontent in the Arab world
Too many "well-meaning" individuals and groups have swallowed the fallacious Palestinian Narrative of Victimhood in the Middle East and fail to recognize that the Christians living there are the real victims. But in one MidEast country Christians thrive
The slaughter and torture of Christians: not a priority for the Government, Labour or DfID The slaughter and torture of Christians: not a priority for the Government, Labour or DfID The slaughter and torture of Christians: not a priority for the Government, Labour or DfID The slaughter and torture of Christians: not a priority for the Government, Labour or DfID
"One hundred thousand Christians will be massacred this year because of their beliefs." Last Tuesday, with these words, Jim Shannon MP (DUP) began a Commons debate on the unfashionable crime against humanity.
Comments
Sally 3/5/2014 12:57 am
There is no Christianity on any North American soil, not at all. All here is sects - nothing other!
Christian Schmemann2/20/2014 5:32 pm
Most of the 'Christian' support for Israel and its apartheid policies comes from American Protestants, and specifically American Evangelical Protestants.

Many average Fundamentalist Protestants in America are completely ignorant that there are even any Christians in the Middle East at all- let alone Palestine. The few average Fundamentalist Protestants in America who are aware of the Christian plight in Palestine (and the Middle East generally) refuse to refuse to us Catholic and Orthodox Christians as being Christian at all, and they blaspheme the Roman Pope, the Greek Patriarch, the Arab Patriarchs and the Russian Patriarch as 'False Prophets' who will be servants of the future Antichrist!

The leaders of the Fundamentalist Protestant 'Churches' (Temples of Satan)are well aware of the Christian plight in Palestine, and actively encourage Israel in its persecutions against Christians in Palestine, and actively work with the Republican Party (and its Tea Party rebels) and media outlets in America to cover up the fact that Israel persecutes Christians.

Besides the Israeli government, the American government is also complicit in the persecution of Christians in the Middle East.
Laura Abraham2/20/2014 4:51 pm
A thoughtful and very accurate piece on the misunderstood and misrepresented plight of Christians in Israel and Palestine. Having been there several times and met with Palestinian Christians, as well as Muslims and Jewish peace activists, it is the Israeli occupation and it's infrastructure that kills hopes for peace and pushes indigenous Christians out of their homeland. Thank you for writing this and I hope it's important message will be read and understood by many, especially Christians in the "West" who have contributed to this problem and have a responsibility to help solve it.
Here you can leave your comment on the present article, not exceeding 4000 characters. All comments will be read by the editors of OrthoChristian.Com.
Enter through FaceBook
Your name:
Your e-mail:
Enter the digits, seen on picture:

Characters remaining: 4000

Subscribe
to our mailing list

* indicates required
×