What is the Price of “Unity”?

The Ecumenical Patriarch's actions in Ukraine have prompted calls for a Synaxis. Patriarch Bartholomew's refusal to convene one has prompted some to suggest suspension, hopefully temporary, of communion with the CP, and an appeal to Alexandria, the next in line, to convene the meeting. There is hesitation, based on concern for unity. In response, many are beginning to ask…

    

What is the price of unity?

Concerns about suspending communion, even temporarily and for a constructive purpose, are well-founded. St. John Chrysostom himself tells us, “Nothing so provokes God's anger as the division of the Church.” Immediately before that, however, he clarifies who the dividers are: “Nothing will so avail to divide the Church as love of power.” 1 The Fathers further make it clear that those who join with schismatics become schismatics themselves.2

A key tactic of the Left is to create division and then to accuse those who object of “divisiveness.” The tactic began to be employed against ecclesiastical institutions in the 1970’s, and by the 1990’s every one of the hitherto strong moral and doctrinal positions of the “mainline churches” had been overthrown. The new “Religious Left,” gaining control of the seminaries and denominational institutions, silenced their opposition—even their highest-ranking opposition—by invoking “church unity.” They then leveraged their positions to impose their agendas through the sheer exercise of power.

Now similar guns are aimed at us.

Again, St. John Chrysostom, from the same homily:

Yea, though we have achieved ten thousand glorious acts, yet shall we, if we cut to pieces the fullness of the Church, suffer punishment no less sore than they who mangled His body.

The Local Churches’ response to the CP’s schismatics has been uncompromising:

Archbishop Theodosius of Boyarka fears a split into Orthodoxy and “Phanarodoxy;” 2

Antioch’s Patriarch John X admonished, “It is unreasonable to end a schism at the expense of the unity of the Orthodox world,” 3 stressing the need for a Synaxis.

Dr. Alexander Shchipkov, professor of philosophy at Moscow State University, proposes an

“inter-Orthodox ecclesiastical court” to “make judgments about the anti-canonical actions and heretical ideas of Patriarch Bartholomew.” 4

Metropolitan Amfilohije of Montenegro has stated, “Constantinople’s lust for power is catastrophic for Orthodoxy.” 5

Archbishop Jovan of Ohrid has called for a Council.6

Finally, Metropolitan Danil of Vididn, Bulgaria, declined to attend the Ukrainian “Unity Council” by quoting from Psalm 1: “Blessed is the man that hath not walked in the counsel of the ungodly, nor stood in the way of sinners, nor sat in the seat of the pestilent. But his will is rather in the law of the Lord, and on His law will he meditate day and night.” 7

Concerns about “encouraging disunity” appear to be waning: if someone leaves the room, those who point out that he has left are not the ones who have departed;

Calls for a Synaxis are virtually unanimous among the Local Churches. Calls are not actions, however, and so far Bartholomew has simply ignored them. Pragmatically, this makes sense: every day that goes by solidifies his position.

Suspending communion with Constantinople would clear the way for a Synaxis. It’s a step nobody wants to take, but It would seem the time has come to consider the cost of not taking it.

Fr, James is Rector of St. Joseph of Arimathea Orthodox Church and House of Prayer, a Western Rite ministry of the Russian Orthodox Church Outside of Russia. His opinions are his own.

Fr. James Rosselli

1/29/2019

1 See Chrysostom, Homily 11 on Ephesians. http://www.newadvent.org/fathers/230111.htm.

2 See must not pray together with heretics or schismatics: An approach to the precise practice (akrivia) of the Church By fr. Anastasios Gotsopoulos, Parish Priest of Saint Nicholas’ Church of Patrae) Δημοσιεύθηκε στις Απριλίου 7th, 2008 at https://alopsis.gr/afieroma/af-one-must-not-pray-together-with-heretics-or-schismatics-an-approach-to-the-precise-practice-akrivia-of-the-church-by-fr-anastasios-gotsopoulos-parish-priest-of-saint-nicholas-c/ for an excellent treatment of this).

3 For Patriarch John X of Antioch, it was unreasonable to put an end to the Ukrainian schism at the price of Orthodox world unity

4 Александр Щипков: патриарх Варфоломей запомнится как учинитель раскола

5 Constantinople’s lust for power is catastrophic for Orthodoxy—Met. Amfilohije of Montenegro

6 Archbishop Jovan of Ohrid: Church needs new council to deal with problem of schismatics (+ VIDEOS)

7 A Bulgarian Hierarch Speaks Out Regarding the Phanariot Crisis in the Ukraine

See also
About Good Doctor Aibolit and the Greek Orthodox Church About Good Doctor Aibolit and the Greek Orthodox Church
Priest Sergei Begiyan
About Good Doctor Aibolit and the Greek Orthodox Church About Good Doctor Aibolit and the Greek Orthodox Church
Priest Sergei Begiyan
To understand that Patriarch Bartholomew is by no means a good doctor, that he pursues completely specific materialistic goals, we must forget for a while about the current conflict and recall another. We must remember the Greek Orthodox Church.
On the Future of Orthodoxy in Ukraine and in the World On the Future of Orthodoxy in Ukraine and in the World
Abp. Theodosy (Snigirev)
On the Future of Orthodoxy in Ukraine and in the World On the Future of Orthodoxy in Ukraine and in the World
A Conversation with Archbishop Theodosy (Snigirev)
Sergei Geruk, Archbishop Theodosy (Snigiryov) of Boyarka
And here are the proud speeches about racial superiority and religious exclusivity: “’O God, I thank Thee,’ and other foolish words…” The Patriarch says such things so openly and pretentiously that it’s even become frightful.
The Interference by the Phanar in the UOC-MP Affairs Divides and not Unites People in the Entire Orthodox World The Interference by the Phanar in the UOC-MP Affairs Divides and not Unites People in the Entire Orthodox World
Archpriest Seraphim Gan
The Interference by the Phanar in the UOC-MP Affairs Divides and not Unites People in the Entire Orthodox World The Interference by the Phanar in the UOC-MP Affairs Divides and not Unites People in the Entire Orthodox World
Archpriest Seraphim Gan
Why does the Phanar act so cautiously with Orthodox in America and yet acts in such an irresponsible way in Ukraine? What is the stand of the ROCOR on the policy of the Phanar in Ukraine?
Getting to the Essence. A Look at the Schism Through the Eyes of Professor Osipov Getting to the Essence. A Look at the Schism Through the Eyes of Professor Osipov
Professor Alexei Osipov
Getting to the Essence. A Look at the Schism Through the Eyes of Professor Osipov Getting to the Essence. A Look at the Schism Through the Eyes of Professor Osipov
Professor Alexei Osipov
The following is a translated transcript of a Spas (Savior) Orthodox TV channel special edition of their program, “Straight to the essence”. In these extremely disturbing times, people want to hear a familiar, trusted voice of experience and sound theology. Professor Osipov is that voice.
A Canonical Crisis in the Orthodox Church A Canonical Crisis in the Orthodox Church
Met. Jonah (Paffhausen)
A Canonical Crisis in the Orthodox Church A Canonical Crisis in the Orthodox Church
Primacy, Conciliarity and the Ecumenical Patriarchate
Metropolitan Jonah (Paffhausen)
The actions of the Patriarchate of Constantinople (EP) in its process of granting a Tomos of autocephaly to the schismatic groups in Ukraine have created a canonical crisis.
How the Phanar Decieved the Ukrainians How the Phanar Decieved the Ukrainians
Fr. George Maximov
How the Phanar Decieved the Ukrainians How the Phanar Decieved the Ukrainians
Priest George Maximov
It kind of makes sense now why Constantinople did it and why they wouldn’t listen to any pleas from other Churches not to do it. It was a low-hanging fruit, so “pleasing to the eye” and so easy for picking.
Comments
Here you can leave your comment on the present article, not exceeding 700 characters. All comments will be read by the editors of OrthoChristian.Com.
Enter through FaceBook
Your name:
Your e-mail:
Enter the digits, seen on picture:

Characters remaining: 700

Subscribe
to our mailing list

* indicates required
×