The Problem of Miracles

Religion acknowledges miracles

The Miracle of the Holy Fire The Miracle of the Holy Fire
    

Some scientists (insufficiently educated in philosophy) categorically reject the possibility of miracles and regard a miracle as contradictory to the laws of nature. Very often such scholars assert that miracles appear to be either a fiction, a fraud, or such a phenomenon which science cannot at present explain, but will certainly be explained scientifically later on. What is unintelligible today might be intelligible and explainable tomorrow.

Science, setting for itself the problem of an exact, objective proof of phenomena investigated experimentally, is fully correct in approaching miraculous phenomena in an attempt at scientific enlightenment. It is without doubt true that often so called miraculous phenomena prove to be not at all miraculous. A fiction or deceit in such cases is lawfully revealed through a scientific method of verification. It is also undoubtedly true that many phenomena, not understood at the present time, may be scientifically explained at some future time. But the problem of a miracle is not fully explained by this.

It is necessary, therefore, first of all, to define what in religion is called a miracle. A miracle is a phenomenon which is unexplainable not only at the present time but, in general, can never be fully explained merely from a scientific point of view. The philosophical problem of a miracle, therefore, arrives at the question: Is a miracle possible? In other words, is such a phenomenon possible which cannot be explained from the point of view of science?

Very often, atheistically and materialistically inclined scholars say that every phenomenon of nature and every event occurring in the world can be explained by the laws of nature alone, without the help of God or of miracles. This is not correct. At least two cases are unexplainable by the laws of nature alone: 1) The very existence of the world or nature, and 2) the laws of nature themselves. Therefore, the existence of the world and its laws are miracles.

Who created the world and the laws of nature? There are not and there cannot be any logical obstacles for the belief that the cause of the world and its laws is God.

The English philosopher, Berkeley (1685-1753), gave this reasoning concerning, the above. The laws of nature, said he, are those means through which God governs the world, and the actions of these laws of nature are actions of God Himself. As a result, where God finds it necessary according to His intentions or plans, He can change these constant methods of His activity in the world so that a phenomenon will occur which is unexplainable by the laws of nature alone; that is, an actual miracle will occur. Almighty God can, whenever lie chooses, even change "the order of nature."

Very often we may happen to hear it said that a miracle contradicts the laws of nature, but the word "contradicts" is out of place here. We will try to analyze this question carefully.

Let us suppose that on the earth everything exists except man and his consciousness. In such a world can a steam engine appear? Of course, it is impossible! But why? All the component parts of the steam engine exist in the world of steel, copper, iron, wood, water, etc. Is it possible that by accidental motion of the particles of which a steam engine is composed, during a long period of time, millions of years, that a steam engine could fabricate itself just by chance? No, this is impossible. Actually, for a steam engine to put in an appearance, the intelligence of the man who designed and made it is a necessity. Without the aid of consciousness, the steam engine is a miracle, even though all its components exist in nature.

As it is, this miracle--the appearance of an engine--does not contradict the laws of nature. All the laws of nature remain inviolate. But they--the laws of inert unconscious nature--are overcome by a new factor, consciousness. In order to explain the miracle of mechanics, a recognition of a "higher factor," consciousness, is necessary.

Now we turn to consciousness itself. Can consciousness be explained by inert, unconscious laws of nature? If these laws could not create a steam engine, even less chance would they have to create something incomparably more complicated -consciousness. (Such nonsense is assumed only by materialists who regard consciousness as a product of evolving matter.) Even consciousness cannot explain itself. Consciousness can create a steam engine, but it cannot create itself. It follows, then that consciousness is also a miracle. To explain this miracle it is necessary to accept even a more complicated, higher and more complete principle, which causes such phenomena like consciousness. This higher cause of consciousness (a higher Intellect) is God, faith in Whom is not impeded by anything found in science or philosophy.

If man's consciousness, meddling with inert and unconscious nature and overcoming it, can make such things (miracles) like steam engines, then the higher, divine Intellect, having created man's consciousness and inert nature, directly intervening in inert nature and overcoming it (by powers unknown to us of His creative, divine Intellect), can create phenomena even more greatly complicated; for instance, to transform water into wine or to resurrect the dead. In these phenomena the laws of nature are not violated; a miracle does not contradict the laws of nature but overcomes them by higher forces unknown to us.

When scholars came to Newton and expressed perplexity in regard to his belief in the future resurrection of bodies, he answered in the following manner: Taking a pile of copper and steel filings and mixing them together, he offered to separate the steel from the copper. Then he took a large magnet and with its help he quickly separated the steel filings from the copper. The Lord God evidently has forces which are more complicated and unknown to us (special magnets), with the help of which He can perform a resurrection of the bodies of all the dead at the future fearful Judgment Nothing interfered with Newton's belief in this.

Ivan M. Andreev

12/27/2014

See also
Catholicos-Patriarch Ilia II relates a miracle that once happened to his mother Catholicos-Patriarch Ilia II relates a miracle that once happened to his mother Catholicos-Patriarch Ilia II relates a miracle that once happened to his mother Catholicos-Patriarch Ilia II relates a miracle that once happened to his mother
“I want to recall my childhood. There was no Sunday or Saturday, when our father, mother, and all of us children missed a church service. Once during the service mother said to us, children: “Stay here, and I will go out.”
From From "On the East". A Miracle of Great Martyr Mercurius
Archpriest Pavel Nedosekin
From From "On the East". A Miracle of Great Martyr Mercurius
Archpriest Pavel Nedosekin
The Monastery possesses a parcel of land on the shores of the Mediterranean Sea in the region of Alexandria. It happened that the defense minister of Egypt took a liking to this parcel of land. So he confiscated the property to build a vacation facility for officers. These documents were personally signed by President Mubarak.
Monastic prayer rescued shipwreck survivors near the Indian coast Monastic prayer rescued shipwreck survivors near the Indian coast Monastic prayer rescued shipwreck survivors near the Indian coast Monastic prayer rescued shipwreck survivors near the Indian coast
This story was recounted by Mother-Superior of the Convent of the Nativity of Christ in the Vyatka Diocese, Abbess Theodosia (Dyachkova).
Greece: Metropolitan testifies to a miracle that happened to him Greece: Metropolitan testifies to a miracle that happened to him Greece: Metropolitan testifies to a miracle that happened to him Greece: Metropolitan testifies to a miracle that happened to him
Metropolitan Benedict promised to thank the saint for his help by gifting a cow to the monastery on the saint’s feast-day.
A new miracle of St. Luke of Crimea occurs in Greece A new miracle of St. Luke of Crimea occurs in Greece A new miracle of St. Luke of Crimea occurs in Greece A new miracle of St. Luke of Crimea occurs in Greece
A new miracle of St. Luke, Archbishop of Crimea, has occurred in the ancient Greek region of the Argolid, in the city of Argos.
Nigerian man survives 3 days at bottom of Atlantic Nigerian man survives 3 days at bottom of Atlantic Nigerian man survives 3 days at bottom of Atlantic Nigerian man survives 3 days at bottom of Atlantic
Dramatic footage shows the unlikely rescue of a ship's cook, who survived for almost three days trapped in an air bubble in his sunken ship.
Comments
Carlos2/7/2015 3:28 am
The biggest problem regarding the rejection of miracles is that many scientists and atheists think that philosophy itself is obsolete and has no use for them. I saw this by the title of some scientist claiming that science not only can replace religion but philosophy as well when it comes to explaining the world. It might be a bold claim but I'm starting to notice that atheism claims to be no longer grounded in philosophy, like in the past, but in science instead and in science alone.
Here you can leave your comment on the present article, not exceeding 700 characters. All comments will be read by the editors of OrthoChristian.Com.
Enter through FaceBook , or enter your information:
Your name:
Your e-mail:
Enter the digits, seen on picture:

Characters remaining: 700

×