Ukrainian schismatics willing to create Romanian vicariate but not to accept re-ordination to facilitate recognition by other Churches

Kiev, March 4, 2019

Photo: spzh.news Photo: spzh.news     

The Ukrainian schismatic church, created on December 15 and given a tomos of autocephaly on January 6, has yet to be recognized as canonical by any Local Church other than the Patriarchate of Constantinople which created it.

However, the primate of the so-called “Orthodox Church of Ukraine” OCU, “Metropolitan” Epiphany Dumenko said in an interview with Pravda today that his church is willing to meet the conditions laid out by the Romanian Holy Synod in its recent statement on the Ukrainian issue.

On the other hand, in a recent interview with BBC Ukraine, he rejected the possibility of its clergy being re-ordained, despite the fact that several Local Churches have expressed either the outright rejection of their clergy or serious reservations about serving with clergy who were ordained while in schism.

In particular, Epiphany considers it acceptable to create a Romanian vicariate within the OCU for the Romanian faithful living in Bukovina.

The Romanian Synod wrote that in order to make a concrete decision about the Ukrainian schismatics, priority will be given to the consideration of the 127 Romanian-language parishes in Ukraine, and that it is necessary to obtain written guarantees from the Church authorities that the Romanians’ ethnicity and language will be respected and that they will have the opportunity to organize into a Romanian vicariate and to cultivate their spiritual connection with the Romanian Patriarchate.

“Of course, we need to negotiate. This statement was just last week. We’ll discuss everything; we’re ready,” Epiphany said, noting, as did the Romanian Synod, that there is a Ukrainian vicariate within the Romanian Church. “Why shouldn’t we give Romanians the same opportunity?” he asked.

The issue will be solved, and the Romanian Church will recognize the schismatics’ autocephaly, Epiphany Dumenko is certain.

However, the schismatic head considers the re-ordination of his clergy to be impossible, although this was also something the Romanian Synod expressed concern about.

The issue of the legitimacy of ordinations celebrated by bishops of the schismatic “Kiev Patriarchate” and the schismatic “Ukrainian Autocephalous Orthodox Church” was resolved when the Patriarchate of Constantinople received all the clergy in their orders on October 11.

“The Ecumenical Patriarchate, which had the right do so, accepted our appeals and decided to receive us in our existing orders,” Dumenko explained. “Constantinople recognized the anathema placed upon Philaret as invalid—accordingly, everything that has happened since then (in particular, the ordinations he has performed) were recognized as valid. Moscow cannot limit the action of the grace of the Holy Spirit,” the schismatic head said.

Recall that the entire Orthodox Church, Pat. Bartholomew included, recognized and accepted the excommunication and subsequent anathematization of Philaret.

Referring to the idea of undergoing re-ordination with the participation of hierarchs from both Moscow and Constantinople as a possible compromise to resolve the situation, the schismatic head said “this is unrealistic and impossible,” and would not be accepted by the Ukrainian people.

The Serbian and Polish Churches have strongly rejected the Ukrainian schismatic church, noting precisely that its clergy are not truly ordained. The Cypriot and Romanian Churches have also highlighted the problem in their statements, and hierarchs from the Greek, Georgian, Cypriot, and Czech-Slovak Churches, have rejected the possibility of serving with un-ordained schismatics.

Follow us on Facebook!

3/4/2019

See also
Each Athonite monastery will decide for itself whether to accept Ukrainian schismatics, 4 Greek monasteries condemn Russian Church’s stance Each Athonite monastery will decide for itself whether to accept Ukrainian schismatics, 4 Greek monasteries condemn Russian Church’s stance Each Athonite monastery will decide for itself whether to accept Ukrainian schismatics, 4 Greek monasteries condemn Russian Church’s stance Each Athonite monastery will decide for itself whether to accept Ukrainian schismatics, 4 Greek monasteries condemn Russian Church’s stance
A regular meeting of the Sacred Community of Mt. Athos was held on February 28, during which the Ukrainian issue and the possibility of the Ukrainian schismatics visiting and serving in Athonite monasteries was raised again.
Archbishop Michael of Prague bans his clergy from serving with Ukrainian schismatics Archbishop Michael of Prague bans his clergy from serving with Ukrainian schismatics Archbishop Michael of Prague bans his clergy from serving with Ukrainian schismatics Archbishop Michael of Prague bans his clergy from serving with Ukrainian schismatics
The clergy of the Prague Diocese of the Church of the Czech Lands and Slovakia have been officially banned from serving with clergy of the schismatic Ukrainian group created by Constantinople on December 15.
It is Unacceptable to Have Eucharistic Communion with Unordained Schismatics It is Unacceptable to Have Eucharistic Communion with Unordained Schismatics
Met. Nikiforos of Kykkos
It is Unacceptable to Have Eucharistic Communion with Unordained Schismatics It is Unacceptable to Have Eucharistic Communion with Unordained Schismatics
Commentary on the Ukrainian Issue for the Cypriot Holy Synod
Metropolitan Nikiforos of Kykkos
I can draw only one conclusion. Sadly enough, Ecumenical Patriarch Bartholomew’s granting of autocephalous status to the schismatic community of Philaret and Epiphany not only did not heal the existing schism in Ukraine, but on the contrary, aggravated it.
Constantinople’s goal is to impose its authority over the entire Church—Met. Daniil of Bulgarian Church Constantinople’s goal is to impose its authority over the entire Church—Met. Daniil of Bulgarian Church Constantinople’s goal is to impose its authority over the entire Church—Met. Daniil of Bulgarian Church Constantinople’s goal is to impose its authority over the entire Church—Met. Daniil of Bulgarian Church
The actions of the Patriarchate of Constantinople, including in Ukraine, show that it’s more important for Patriarch Bartholomew to impose his power over the Orthodox Church than to find consent and unity, His Eminence Metropolitan Daniil of Vidin of the Bulgarian Orthodox Church stated to RIA-Novosti yesterday.
Epiphany Dumenko is impostor, says Met. Rostislav of Czech-Slovak Church Epiphany Dumenko is impostor, says Met. Rostislav of Czech-Slovak Church Epiphany Dumenko is impostor, says Met. Rostislav of Czech-Slovak Church Epiphany Dumenko is impostor, says Met. Rostislav of Czech-Slovak Church
His Beatitude Metropolitan Rostislav of the Czech Lands and Slovakia visited Moscow over the weekend for the celebration of the 10th anniversary of the enthronement of His Holiness Patriarch Kirill as the primate of the Russian Church, where he celebrated the Divine Liturgy at his Church’s representation parish of St. Nicholas of Myra on Sunday, February 3—the same day that “Metropolitan” Epiphany Dumenko was enthroned as the primate of the Ukrainian schismatics in Kiev.
Kiev schema-archimandrite appeals to Georgian Church not to recognize Ukrainian schismatics Kiev schema-archimandrite appeals to Georgian Church not to recognize Ukrainian schismatics Kiev schema-archimandrite appeals to Georgian Church not to recognize Ukrainian schismatics Kiev schema-archimandrite appeals to Georgian Church not to recognize Ukrainian schismatics
A schema-archimandrite of the Zverinets Monastery of the Archangel Michael in Kiev has appealed to the Georgian Orthodox Church to support the canonical Ukrainian Church in its time of persecution and not recognize the schismatic Ukrainian structure.
Czech hierarch: What is happening in Ukraine is unbelievable Czech hierarch: What is happening in Ukraine is unbelievable Czech hierarch: What is happening in Ukraine is unbelievable Czech hierarch: What is happening in Ukraine is unbelievable
The way that the authorities in Ukraine use the Church for political purposes and to cover their own sins is unbelievable, His Eminence Archbishop Juraj of Michalovce and Košice of Slovakia commented in an interview with the Information-Education Department of the Ukrainian Orthodox Church yesterday.
A Canonical Crisis in the Orthodox Church A Canonical Crisis in the Orthodox Church
Met. Jonah (Paffhausen)
A Canonical Crisis in the Orthodox Church A Canonical Crisis in the Orthodox Church
Primacy, Conciliarity and the Ecumenical Patriarchate
Metropolitan Jonah (Paffhausen)
The actions of the Patriarchate of Constantinople (EP) in its process of granting a Tomos of autocephaly to the schismatic groups in Ukraine have created a canonical crisis.
Chauvinists, politicians, Uniates, and Constantinople spread schism in Ukraine, says Serbian Church (+ VIDEO) Chauvinists, politicians, Uniates, and Constantinople spread schism in Ukraine, says Serbian Church (+ VIDEO) Chauvinists, politicians, Uniates, and Constantinople spread schism in Ukraine, says Serbian Church (+ VIDEO) Chauvinists, politicians, Uniates, and Constantinople spread schism in Ukraine, says Serbian Church (+ VIDEO)
In the epistle, the Serbian hierarchs touch upon the sad phenomenon of schism that affects the Orthodox world today, and especially in Ukraine. They begin by reminding the departed “Macedonian Orthodox Church” that autocephaly is an ecclesiastical privilege that does not belong to the political sphere.

Subscribe
to our mailing list

* indicates required
×